Rollover Government TSP To 401k

I currently have some money, only about $2k, in a government Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) from a federal job I worked a few years ago. First, should I bother rolling this over into my current 401k? Second, would there be any penalties incurred by doing so? Third, are there any advantages or disadvantages to keeping the investments, TSP and 401k separated?

Thanks in advance.

Reply to
joshbilsky
Loading thread data ...

Can't you roll it into a Traditional IRA? This will give you more flexibility when it comes to investment choices.

I don't see major, if any, advantages of rolling it into a

401(k)...

wrote

Reply to
Elle

You can roll your TSP in to an IRA or qualified employer plan (e.g.

401k) with no penalty. Whether or not you SHOULD do so is another matter. Here are some things to think about: 1) Account fees. As far as I know, the TSP has no account fees. If you roll your money in to an IRA, the IRA custodian will most certainly charge you an account fee (especially because of the low account). These fees are generally pretty reasonable, maybe $10 per year. On the other hand, if you're enrolled in your company's 401k, you're already paying the account fee for that. Rolling your TSP in to your 401k won't incur any additional fee. 2) Expense ratios. The funds in the TSP have ridiculously low expense ratios. The S&P 500 index fund, for example, has only a .05% expense ratio. You'd be hard pressed to find expense ratios that low anywhere else. 3) Roth conversion. Rolling your money in to an IRA opens up the possibility for a Roth conversion. Whether or not the conversion would be beneficial to you is beyond the scope of this post. You can find a LOT of discusson on Roth vs. traditional IRA in this newsgroup. 4) Investment opportunities. As Elle pointed out, if you roll your money in to an IRA, you'll have the full range of investment opportunities open to you. If you roll the money in to your 401k, you'll be limited by the plan's fund choices. However, some 401k plans offer unique investment opportunities that you might want to take advantage of. 5) Simplification. This is really a matter of personal taste. If you're the sort of person who can't or won't keep track of a lot of little accounts (or, like me, just doesn't want to), it's probably worth your while to consolidate.

Lots of food for thought. Without knowing more about your situation, my default advice is to roll the money in to an IRA and then do the Roth conversion. The Roth is simple and it affords you more flexibility with your money.

--Bill

Reply to
woessner

I would roll the TSP over to a traditional IRA then consider converting some or all of it to a Roth IRA if you are under the income cap. Also, consider contributing to a Roth each year after 401k contribution up to employer matching amount.

Good Luck. BeachBum

Reply to
BeachBum

I think Bill's response was very informative and accurate. As he said, whether you should or not depends on several factors.

Personally, I would likely transfer the money for convenience. There would be no penalties.

However, should you decide to keep your money in the TSP, you might want to join the TSP Strategy group. Its a group of Feds who are attempting to work together to maximize their returns in the TSP. Pay TSP allocation services are tracked and discussed also. Its at

formatting link

Reply to
Sarah

On a percentage basis with such a small account, this fee will eat you alive.

Excellent point. You simply cannot find a cheaper expense ratio than the TSP.

True, but the TSP offers an opportunity that is not available anywhere else:

The G Fund

The G Fund is a bond fund that has:

Zero credit risk (because it's invested solely in special securities issued by the Treasury).

A yield that's about what you'd get in an intermediate bond fund. (Currently about 4.5 percent.)

And a net asset value (share price) THAT CAN NEVER GO DOWN.

That's because the G Fund has an intermediate maturity, but a duration that's measured in days.

Pretty cool, yes?

One last point -- If the original poster ever comes back to work for the federal government he can pick up where he left off contributing to the TSP>

My advice? Leave the money in the TSP, put it all in the G fund, and check back at age 70.

Reply to
Paul Michael Brown

I would take it the other way. Put it all in an equity index fund (large cap or total market) and leave it until 70.

The reason being the average return is likely to exceed 4.5% pa, over a

30 year period, say. Over a very long run, the downside risk is more about inflation, and about real income growth (which makes you feel worse off, even if your investments have grown), than about losing money in capital terms.

At 7% pa and 30 years: 8 times

at 8% and 30 years: c. 10 times

If one had a 12% return (about the return from an SP500 index fund with low costs over the last 30 years, I believe) then that would be 30 times. I don't however expect equity returns to be anything like that in the future.

Reply to
darkness39

My own thought is you should hold the TSP in an all equity index fund, and leave it.

The reason being costs are very low, and you are maximising expected return. It's basically a roll of the dice, and assuming you have another 30 years to work, it could easily be 8 times the size it is right now (doubling every 10 years ie a 7% average return pa) or even

12 times (doubling every 9 years ie an 8% pa return). $16k is a handy chunk of change even in tomorrow's inflation eaten dollars.

You won't be planning to retire on this money, but it might turn out to be a nice bonus. Say it turns into $16k, then that might buy an annuity at 65 of $60pcm ($720 pa at a 4.5% annuity rate).

The biggest disadvantage I can see is that when you do come to retire and buy an annuity, you will be disadvantaged because of the small size you are trying to buy.

Reply to
darkness39

Well, I think I will take the general consensus here and leave this money in TSP. As has been mentioned, this is such a small amount that it is really nothing more than a bonus. So, if I understand this correctly, the G fund is 0 risk but small return. Since this money is going to sit in TSP for a long time, wouldn't it be a better idea to do what darkness said and put it in the large cap or total market to get higher return? Also, I take it that we're all in agreement that it is better to put this small amount of money into one fund rather than diversify? Right now I still have the money allocated to several of the funds.

-JB

Reply to
Joshua Bilsky

What TSP funds to pick depends on:

1) your desired asset allocation 2) your other retirement investment options 3) your taxable investment options

The general idea is what you want to put your higher distribution/higher yield options in retirement accounts. After that, you decide which retirement plan has better options for each of the categories you are interested in.

Joshua Bilsky wrote:

Reply to
wyu

the general consensus here and leave this money in

And for this reason, I wouldn't think too hard about the tax implications or the position re your overall portfolio (all types of accounts). If you had more money, that would be relevant. But in this case, you really want to max out your expected return.

In a vague way, this is the equivalent of putting the entire bet on 29 Red at the casino. However, equity funds return better than casino bets! You are very unlikely to lose all your money (after inflation), and there is a good chance you could create a tidy little lump sum for yourself when you are 65.

In fact, I would either put it in the I fund (international stocks) or the C fund (common stocks). There is a case for the S fund (small stocks) but that would be at least as risky as the I fund, and perhaps more so.

(I'd have to go into a long aside here about my feelings about small cap stocks. Which basically boil down to the high returns are so well known, that I believe going forward they won't return as much relative to large stocks as they have done, and therefore the investor is better off not trying to grab that higher return (which in any case always came with higher risk).

So, if I understand this correctly, the G fund

If it is the government bond fund, that would be true. The lowest risk is the government TIPS (inflation indexed bond) fund.

Since this money is going to sit in TSP for a

Total market fund probably has the highest risk and highest potential return. An international stock fund is the other alternative. See above.

Also, I take it that

I would go with that.

Right now I still have the money

Reply to
darkness39

Thanks for your insight. I think I'm going to move it all into the C fund. The C fund seems like it experiences relatively stable growth compared to the I fund which seems much more volatile. For such a small amount of investment, there's probably not much for me to lose for being more aggresive. I won't be relying on this as a primary retirement funding source. If it was a lot more money, I'd probably do what Paul said and throw it in the G fund.

Reply to
Joshua Bilsky

Thanks for your insight. I think I'm going to move it all into the C

That's probably true. The I fund has 2 levels of risk: 1. stocks and

  1. the US dollar against the foreign currencies in which it is invested.

I think what you want to do now is forget it for at least 20 years....

For such a

For any period of less than 20 years, you really can't bank on it. But for over 20 years, you have a good chance of coming out best with C fund. And best by a factor of 2-4 times the money (assuming you are investing for 30 years).

Reply to
darkness39

OF COURSE the S&P 500 (C Fund) has outperformed a portfolio of intermediate/long government bonds (G Fund) over the *past* decades. And while that performance doesn't guarantee what the *future* holds, I quibble not with the assumption that the future will look like the past.

But everybody is missing my point. The original poster can invest in the S&P 500 in any number of ways going forward. And I assume he will do so. But his TSP account and the G Fund presents him with an opportunity to invest in a vehicle that he cannot find anywhere else. Granted, it's a trivial amount of money. But why not put it in the G Fund and use that to diversify his equity holdings in other accounts?

Reply to
Paul Michael Brown

BeanSmart website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.