bank error in minimum distribution -

I noticed what appears to be an error in my bank's required minimum distribution calculation. I am a beneficiary where the former ira owner died before the required beginning date. I have been taking distributions based on the single life expectancy minus x years formula. It appears that my bank has been erroneously calculating single life expectancy anew each year, resulting in 5-10% lower distributions than my true RMD in year 2 and beyond. Two questions:

1) Must I file form 5329, since the 5329 instructions state "If the trustee, custodian, or issuer of your IRA informs you of the minimum required distribution, you can use that amount." Or should I file 5329 showing no excess accumulations and therefore no tax? Or should I calculate it the RMD on my own, show the tax, and write the excuse letter? 2) This has been happenning for 2 years. Are excess accumulations additive, in that if I were $100 short in 2005, and $200 short in 2006, do I owe tax on 50% of $300 in 2006? I see this logic in the 590 for excess contributions, but not excess accumulations.

-MVL

> > > > > > > > >
Reply to
mvl_groups_user
Loading thread data ...

If a significant amount of money is involved you might hire a tax attorney to (1) research the issue or (2) obtain a letter ruling from the IRS. Kreig Mitchell

formatting link
formatting link

Reply to
Kreig Mitchell

depending on the distribution options chosen, it may be correct ___________________________________

-----> real address on hobokeni or hobokenx

Reply to
Benjamin Yazersky CPA
[clip]
[clip]

As a non professional wicked in spread sheet skills, I have been forecasting my own "What if's" regarding my 401K. One of the observations that complicated the math prediction formulas for "Required Minimum Distributions" surprised me, but makes sense if you think about it. Publication 590, "Life Expetantcy Tables" shows that we are "expected" to live longer each year that we get older. In other words, the older you get, the older you are expected to get. It increases a fractional year each year you survive. The actual RMD is a victim of that complication since life expectancy is a moving target.

Reply to
lurker

BeanSmart website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.