Roth 401K vs. "Regular" 401K?

Anyone have opinions one way or the other here? My large company as of today is offering a Roth 401K. I am within striking distance (1-5 years perhaps?) of retirement, and have funded my regular 401K to the max over the last quarter century.

But now I am in a quandary as to whether to 'sign up' for the Roth 401K, or simply keep making 'regular' 401K contributions in 2008.

A pointer to a calculator or reference on the web is also welcomed, as is of course opinions here in the NG.

Thanks and happy new year!

Reply to
Andrew
Loading thread data ...

Well, it starts with a peak at

formatting link
for you to see what bracket you are in now, and to plan for retirement.There are a number of variable for you to ponder: Current tax bracket, bracket at retirement due to withdrawals from the 401(k) and other income, Social Security income and whether you are subject to having it taxed, married vs single, and any other income you might have upon retiring.You offer no numbers, so I'll guess the 401(k) is approximately $750K. In which case, the 4% withdrawal rule (see other posts here and at m.i.f.p for further details on this) means a withdrawal of about $30,000 per year. This may put you right in the Social Security phantom rate bubble I discussed at
formatting link
some time back.If your 401(k) is much higher (than my guess) you may already be beyond that phantom rate bubble, and unable to avoid it, except by delaying SS benefits, doing the Roth 401(k) while you can, and converting some of the 401(k) first to an IRA and then to a Roth upon retiring.There is no definite answer without some hard numbers.JOE

Reply to
joetaxpayer

BeanSmart website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.