Ally Bank CD - 1yr vs 5yr (w/penalty)

Apr 04, 2012 2 Replies

rates



As the first CD is coming due in June, was wondering about a comment that I read.



Instead of going with the 1yr @ 1.0%, go with the 5yr @ 1.74% and forfeit the 60day penalty interest if we need to withdraw for investing in other high yield funds...



Does this make sense ?


Actually, given today's rates, only 2 of Ally's CDs are ever optimal. The rest should all be ignored. If you think you might withdraw your money within 130 days, you should go with the no-penalty (11 month) CD. Otherwise, you should go with the 5-year CD. After 130 days, the additional interest will more than cancel out any early withdrawal penalty.

I drafted a spreadsheet that dem> Currently have a couple of CD's with Ally bank

in a

Tnx for the reply and posting. The CD's are just a way to keep my hands off, and not add to my various stock & mutual fund holdings, along with providing a parking place for cash... It's about $100k -

I had not actually sat and played with the numbers to see if the 5yr made sense - even with a withdrawl to potentially place the funds into a higher return account if and when that might happen.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required