Re: cap gain

In any case he has a gain upon sale and it would sure be

> taxable. > > If this is business equipment, it is reported on a 4797 and > ends up ordinary income. If personal use property, long > term gain, not a collectible unless the Secretary has > determined that musical instruments are collectibles.

Form 4797 is used for sale of business assets and provides inputs to various other tax forms. Recapture of depreciation produces an entry of ordinary income on(assuming he used the instrument as an employee under misc. income on Form 1040. The profit from price appreciation on business equipment above the orignal basis before depreciation is a capital gain so Form 4797 carries entries to Sch D where the calculations are performed. Bill Patch

> > > > > > > > >
Reply to
BillPatch
Loading thread data ...

Tks so much for a very engaging response. I will follow this and see exactly what happens. will post if I hear anything.

bill

Reply to
Billy

I have a vague recollection that really valuable violins, bows, and such cannot be depreciated even if used in a business context because they do not have a determinable life. If I buy the "Mona Lisa" for use in my private pay-to-look museum, can I depreciate it?

-- Don EA in Upstate NY

Reply to
Don Priebe

One 9th Circuit case (Browning) said that the taxpayer couldn't depreciate his violin, but that case was based on the fact the taxpayer presented no evidence of any kind. That was also a pre-ERTA case, and later courts say that it doesn't apply. A 2nd Circuit case (Simon) says that violins and bows can be depreciated if it can be shown that they are actually subject to wear and tear. Something that isn't used and as a result won't wear out (e.g. a painting hanging on the wall) cannot be depreciated. The tax court seems to agree (Simon).

Stu

Reply to
Stuart Bronstein

BeanSmart website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.