Taxpayer gives me a 1099G from NYS for 2005 overpayment received in 2006. So, I check the 1099G to the 2005 tax return. The NY return (IT203) had a balance due. I notice the amount on the 1099G matches line 71 of form IT203. That line is penalty for underpayment of estimated tax (IT2105.9) It appears that NYS is reporting the penalty for underpayment of estimated tax as a tax refund. There is no taxable income to report. The 1099G is erroneous. So, I call the phone # on the back of the 1099G. After being on hold for about 45 min, I finally am able to get through to a supervisor who could do nothing more than a bureauocratic it's right because we did it & we did it because it`s right & if you don't like it go call someone else. It appears that the way NY process tax returns is that they take your full payment and applied it to the taxes, generating an overpayment that was then applied to the pay the penalty. It's this phantom overpayment thats reported on the 1099G. That would make it a systemic problem. This could cause the IRS to send out notices for mismatches on the 1099G's. Anyone else see this?
- posted
17 years ago