foreign currency - exchange vs bank

Dec 03, 2009 5 Replies

quick question for the knowledge of the group



Foreign Currency exchange rates...



Our son is in Germany for a year, and we have sent him some Euros for birthday etc.



Why is the exchange rate quoted on TV or Yahoo Finance different from the banks (Chase & BOA) when they say they don't charge any fees or commissions ???



ie - Wells Fargo - $100 = 159.18 euro Chase - $100 = 158.89 euro



Yahoo - $100 = 150.48 euro


Are the quotes for buying euros with dollars or buying dollars with euros.

Certain quotes (e.g. WSJ) are for $1,000,000 transactions.

Final note - my MasterCard at an ATM machine has always been better than any change rate or bank even after the MC 2 to 3% commission (Euros in Italy in 2005, Pounds in England 2007, Shekels in Israel in 2009). In previous travels I found banks better than money changers in Hong Kong, Tahiti, Denmark, Spain, Netherlands and cash always better than travelers checks.

ooops - wrong order -

Wells Fargo - 100 euro = $159.18 Chase - 100 euro = $158.89

Yahoo - 100 euro = $150.48

--

[snip]

Banks and airports charge 6% (last I recall) (ripoff). American Express may offer currency conversions at more reasonable rates (for small amounts), via travelers cheques. Best bet is to look in Germany for a dedicated exchange shop. If your son is in the military or diplomatic corps or other, he might have access to better conversions. Might also ask Western Union. The futures quotes you see are for 125k USD (I think that's right - haven't checked on it). Banks trade

*their* stuff at futures quotes!:-) Cards may charge like $85 bucks if you charge something in a foreign country, I think 3% for a cash advance.

MaterCard and Visa charge a 1% fee for withdrawals from foreign currency ATMs. Any fee above 1% is being imposed by your bank/financial institution.

======================================= MODERATOR'S COMMENT: Please trim the post to which you respond. "Trim" means that except for some brief material to provide context for your remarks, the previous post is deleted. Thank you.

The foreign currency exchange outfits that say there are "no fees or commissions" are telling a half truth. They are using a very wide bid/offer spread to make money.

For example if the Euro is at $1.50 the bank will buy Euros for $1.41 and sell them for $1.59. A fairer dealer will have a narrower spread, say buy $1.48 and sell $1.52.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required