Here's the problem in following your direction:
(1) There is no John Doe checking account to enter a disbursement from. We're not sure what JD Chkg acct you're referring to, or how/why it came into existence. John Doe would never have a checking account on the company books; John is an employee of the company and was spending money out of a Petty Cash account set up for him.
(2) Entering the reciept of $20 into the company checking account, resulting in a zero balance in an Exchange" account is not the result we need. While we indeed need to receive the $20 into the company checking account, receiving that $20 needs to result in a zero balance in the "Petty Cash - John Doe" account.
Here's what we did that seemed to work:
(1) From the register for "Petty Cash - John Doe," we entered a $20 payment and posted it to the Company Checking account. There was no Payee entered, but the Memo read "Return unused cash."
(2) The result was a credit to "Petty Cash - John Doe," and a debit to "Company Checking," which zeroed-out the Petty Cash - John Doe account.
I'd like to hear from anyone who can offer a clear list of "do this" in case we got it wrong.
Thank you.