Reconciled transaction disappears

I'm running Windows ME and Quicken Deluxe 2001. I reconcile my checking account monthly. This month a previously reconciled transaction disappeared from the reconciliation process.

This month I clicked on Reconcile and up popped Reconciliation Notice that said "The total of the previously cleared items in your register no longer matches with the ending balance of your prior statements. ..." I clicked on Resolve and Quicken indicated only my most recent previous reconciliation was off, and that by $153.23. Very strange, because I do have a reconciled $153.23 transaction in the register from the most recent reconciliation. I selected that latest statement and clicked on Reconcile Again. The window that popped up had the correct Opening Balance and Ending Balance so I clicked on OK.

The list of previous reconciled entries that pops up does not show that $153.23 reconciled transaction that is in the register. The transaction is neither reconciled nor non-reconciled; that transaction just does not appear. I exported the transactions in that account to a QIF file and the transaction does appear.

With a copy (made by Windows, not Quicken) of my Quicken file I tried a validate--no errors. I tried a super validate -- no errors. Then I cleared (removed the "R") the Clr field of that $153.23 transaction and reentered it. I followed that with reentering the R in the Clr field. Doing so seemed to fix the problem, at least the symptom of what might be a larger problem. None of my other accounts have a reconcile problem.

Does anyone have a guess about what happened or what to do? I'm leaning toward just making that single change to the $153.23 record. I do have a 4-week old backup with the reconciled $153.23 transaction and without the reconcile problem. However, more recent backups do have the problem.

Tom

Reply to
MrTom
Loading thread data ...

I suspect the transaction had its status changed at some point. Clearing and then re-entering it fixed the problem, so all is good.

Reply to
L

Older versions of Quicken, including Q2001 I'm fairly sure, had a bug which could cause a previous reconcile to become out of balance ... if you modified the category of a reconciled transaction. (I don't recall the details, but I don't think it was consistent, I don't think that every time the category of a reconciled transaction was changed, the reconcile became out of balance).

I believe there were several discussions of the problem in this newsgroup, you chould check the archives.

I think the "solution" was to click "Resolve", then delete every reconcile through the oldest that was marked in error ... then re-reconcile.

Reply to
John Pollard

Thank you for your status change guess, but I don't I ever manually changed the status of the transaction. I had thought that clearing and then reentering with the "R" fixed things, but I found doing so turned off reconciling. However, clearing (removing the R and entering) and then going through the reconcile->resolve process->reconcile again process did work because that disappearing transaction was now visible.

Tom

Reply to
MrTom

How do you delete a reconcile?

I searched for mention of the disappearing problem and found several hits that did not quite apply. They are probably out there, but I did not run into them.

My "fix" of clearing status of the disappearing transaction -> enter -> reinstituting the R status -> enter had the unwanted side effect of turning off the reconcile feature. What did work was clearing (removing the R and entering) which caused the disappearing transaction to be visible in the reconcile->resolve->re-reconcile process.

Thanks for your many, many contributions to this newsgroup.

Reply to
MrTom

I am no longer able to access "Smart Reconcile" (the feature/process that makes the Resolve button available), so I can not verify that my memory is correct. But I think you right-click the statement while in the Resolve dialog ... then you see a menu that allows you to delete the statement. If not exact, I think that's close.

I don't remember the details, but I definitely remember reading about the problem (that's where I learned whatever I know ... the problem never happened to me).

Look for "reconcile bug" (or variations on the theme), and (or) look for posts by Peter Ricciardiello.

Yes; manually un-reconciling a transactions supposedly turns off Smart Reconcile. I think the only way to turn it back on is to manually reconcile the same transaction tjat was manually un-reconciled. Trouble is, Smart Reconcile is one of the most "secret" features in Quicken that I have ever come into contact with ... so I can't really give you any specifics that I have confidence in.

Reply to
John Pollard

Dear friend : It is my fortunate writing to you . you will discover this is a wealth accumulation place. The website of our company is

formatting link
are a big agent for LaptopMobile Phone\Digital Camera\CDJ\DJM\Apple Ipod\PSP\VEDEO GAMES\Television\GPS\Telescope in CHINA .All of our commodities is the most advanced quality but lowest price.we also have the

safest and most convenient transaction way to guarante the transaction arries on normally . looking forward to your coorporation and cause all of us both to profit. you can contact us by Email:china.seller#hotmail.com MSN: china.seller#hotmail.com best wishes! your sincerely

formatting link
snipped-for-privacy@hotmail.com

Reply to
www.china-powerseller.com

BeanSmart website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.