I have 4 credit cards, and 3 store cards, with credit limits ranging from
250-10,000.
My credit history on all cards should be pretty good. The balance on all cards would usually be paid in full on a monthly basis.
Does having this number of cards affect my credit rating positively or negatively? Would I better to 'kill off' the cards I don't really use?
There's no particular reason for asking, mostly just curious about how the 'system' works :)
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
J
Jonathan Bryce
Probably positively, as it shows you are able to pay loans off on time. It will depend on the particular lender though.
Z
Zoe Brown
There is no such thing as a rating. Data about how you deal with credit is collected and when you apply for credit a company might look at your file. They will use their own criteria to "score" you and decide if you are worth the risk. Generally having lots of credit and paying it off on time looks good but there might be a point when a company will not lend if they consider you have too much credit.
>
T
Tim
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Really?
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Isn't that a "rating"??
Z
Zoe Brown
yes, there is no one rating that exists...
T
Tim
"Zoe Brown" wrote
I don't agree.
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Of course, because there are *many*. But you said before "there is no such thing...", which I contend is *false*.
Z
Zoe Brown
I said "there is no such thing as A credit rating". I then went on to summarise how the scoring system works...
T
Tim
"Zoe Brown" wrote
But there *is* such a thing as "a credit rating". Bank1 will assess "a credit rating" if you apply there, Bank2 will assess (possibly a different) "credit rating" if you apply there etc etc.
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Exactly. You started off by saying that there wasn't such a thing as a credit rating, then you went on to describe one. How silly!
Z
Zoe Brown
A - as in singluar !!
R
Ronald Raygun
A isn't singular, it's generic. That includes both singular and plural. So although you might think it's singular, it's actually hyper-plural.
You might have gotten away with it had you emphasised it to start with. But you haven't, so you've now painted yoruself into a corner.
Z
Zoe Brown
Jesus Christ !!! Someone asks for advice and I try to explain. More than you and Tom tried to do. I only joined this NG last week and now it is time to say goodbye. What is the point, I obviosuly don't have time to write a formal essay for each answer and if you guys are just here to nit pick then fine.
Bye.
>
T
Tim
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Would you also say "there is no such thing as a car"? [Just because there is more than one type of car...]
Z
Zoe Brown
Would you say that posting cr*p like this helps the OP ?
T
Tim
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Not necessarily, but we can hope that it might help *you* - so that you don't make mistakes when you reply next time!
Z
Zoe Brown
Except I posted some information that might actually have helped, you however did not. Further more you were unable to understand what I had written. you are an idiot !!
T
Tim
"Zoe Brown" wrote
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Well, I did point out an issue which may have confused the OP from your reply. Surely that could have been useful?
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Actually, I understood very well what you "actually" wrote, and also what you *tried* to write - but which, unfortunately, you hadn't written properly. I therefore pointed out where your reply could confuse the OP.
"Zoe Brown" wrote
Your basis is...?
S
Square eyes
I worked as a programmer for a bank and got to see their credit scoring process for someone applying for one of their credit cards. Their scoring doesn't mind if you have 2 or 3 credit cards - in fact it means other instituitions trust you. However, like you say, too many and it gets suspicious as to why you'd want another credit card and your rating takes a big (possibly unrecoverable) hit. Different institutions may vary what is an acceptable number of live accounts.
Based on what I saw, I wrote a program that will give you some idea of what you're asking. Here's a free way of getting some idea of what your credit rating would be and how to improve it. It uses the same style of scoring process as the banks but becuase you are answering the questions (not equifax) there's no charge. It'll also work out you estimated credit limit.
Direct download :
formatting link
(633K) Web site :
formatting link
All I ask is that if you do decide to get another credit card, please check out the one I have advertised :)
Thanks, Michael
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.