I'm considering this deal from the Portman, which I found on
formatting link
(a rebranded version of Charcol) I had a long chat with a broker the other day, who despite saying he could source any product on the market, insisted on pushing First Active mortgages at me. Presumably higher commission for him. I told him about the Portman deal and he said it had to be about the best going. However I am very much having second thoughts about fixed-rate mortgages at present, as most signs are that rates will go down. Depends whether you're willing to take the risk. My view is that the plethora of fixed-rate deals being launched at the moment is because the lenders do see rates falling in the near term, and want to lock as many people as possible into current rates.
One useful suggestion the broker made was to hang on for a few weeks as the mortgage lenders will all be working on their new deals during January and we should see some better deals coming out towards the end of the month.
As regards up-front charges, if you can afford to pay them up-front, simply amortise them over the expected term of the mortgage (25 months in the case of the Portman, assuming you will only maintain the mortgage for the discount period), add this to the monthly payment and then work out which is really cheapest. Often it's cheaper over the term to pay a high up-front cost, as the lenders just roll the costs into the monthly payments otherwise.
Jeremy