I have 3 accounts at Ally Bank - 2 CD's and a MMA - Using Quicken 2009 and lots of over accounts work just fine.
It appears that there is something different with Ally depending upon how the Quicken account is created.
Scenario #1 - Using the normal Add Account - Quicken goes thru the normal steps and creates the account, enables Web Express, BUT there are blanances downloaded
Scenario #2 - Using the Ally Bank download screen - and letting Quicken then setup the account during the download yields a slightly different setup using Web Connect. BUT the balances are downloaded and correct.
SO - With the Add Account - you get the Web Express, but no balances.
With the manual Download - you get the Web Connect, with balances. If you then try to enable One Step for this account, you get back to scenario #1.
I did just compare the accounts - since we have 3 of each now - The ones with Web EXpress and no balances have a different set of account number/routing info ie - Web Express account has - account number = xxxxx1234 and "blank" routing no balances
Web Connect account has - account number = 89891234 and real routing number = balances