Retirement Program

Sep 20, 2006 12 Replies

I would like to have a good retirement planning program to run to checkout/validate Quicken's version. Any suggestions?


Make a spreadsheet. It will be transparent, frustrating, and will expose the grubby details. Very rewarding and informative if you do it honestly.

I've looked at moneytree.com's silver planner. It's too expensive, but for your purposes you could use a trial version. They have useful example on their web page as well. Here is a page with some other examples:

formatting link

-- jim

DG wrote:

That's a good list, although very simple comparisons. Not too many details to help a person understand the capabilities of each tool. It also doesn't consider J & L Planner

formatting link
which shows up on every web search for financial planning software. I'm looking for something that works for a very detailed financial plan that has many changes in income, and expenses in the future. I could pay our financial planner $3k a pop to enter our data into a software tool they use, or buy software for much less and do it myself. I'm not afraid to fork out the $$$ if it's a worthy program. I've found some that cost as much as $850 but all of these products seem to be so elusive that it's hard to know if they are worth their weight or not.

If anyone has any experience with any of the programs mentioned, I'd like to hear about your experience.

Cheers, Scott

Any chance you have a Fidelity IRA or 401(k)? They have online retirement planners.

Vanguard has a comprehensive retirement analyzer. It is free for account over a certain size. It's yet another Monte Carlo simulation. Of course, you need to be able to state major expenses and when they occur. Not to mention estimating how long you will live. So, are you going to have to pay for a quadruple heart bypass operation or are you going to have to pay for insurance to hedge against this expense? I believe the future is too complex to be able to predict in a meaningful way. But that is just me.

DP wrote:

What is your motive to try to diswade me from taking control of my future?

In addition to a one-size-fits-all retirement guesser, you also need a spelling checker.

Is everyone on this group a jerk, or just you and Stubby?

"Scott Lindner" wrote

Add an automatic spring loaded remove-foot-from-mouth device to that list.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required