Can VAT registration mean less profit?

Hi there

I've been trading on Ebay (over the last few months) and my turnover is rapidly approaching the VAT threshold.

With this is mind I've worrying about what effect this will have.

Now (hypothetically speaking) say if I buy something for 80 + 14 VAT and it then sells for 100 I make 6 profit.

However, if I was VAT registered the would the following be correct (as I'm not entirely sure how this cursed system is supposed to work )?

The item still costs me 80 + 14 Input VAT.

So if I still want to make 6 profit then the auction would have to close @ 86 but now there would also be 15.05 Output VAT. Thus would the customer would now have to send 101.05 instead of 100?

Obviously though 6 profit would still have been made (as I've done figures that way).

However if the auction closes at the original 100 then "post registration" would I only make 5.10 instead of 6 profit?

So in effect will being VAT registered mean a 17.5% reduction in profits for me? Everything else being equal.

Reply to
Graeme Nicholson
Loading thread data ...

If your business is doing so well, then why have'nt you asked your accountant this basic question?

Reply to
Stephen GoldenGun

It is something that is quite serious, and will make a huge difference in terms of profit...

You need to understand the basics of your business..

So it is worth paying an accountant..to get sound advice....

Reply to
Stephen GoldenGun

In article , Graeme Nicholson writes

It is a "Value Added Tax", so you actually end up paying 17.5% on the value you add. So, in priciple, the answer is yes.

However, it becomes complicated when buying from non vat registered sellers, and selling as a vat registered seller.

You need your accountants help

Reply to
Richard Faulkner

Stephen, meet Graeme. Graeme, meet Stephen. You have so much in common, I'm sure you'll get on well ...

Reply to
Stephen Burke

Because Mr Nicholson like to have his crazy VAT scams given the once over by the members of this group first.

For a change he has asked a sensible question.

(The answer is yes BTW, as real world traded has to put his prices up, unfortunately an ebay trader doesn't have this option)

Tim

Reply to
tim

Although you can state that VAT will be added to the winning bid.

Reply to
Doug Ramage

In message , Stephen GoldenGun writes

Why would he need an accountant?

Reply to
john boyle
I

No, 14.89% but rounded to 15% in your example.

Your arithmetic was correct up to this point.

when you sell at £100, £14.89 is VAT not £17.50.

Your reduced profit of £5.10 is 85% of £6, so your profit is reduced by

15%.

Paying an accountant to tell you this would be a waste of money.

Reply to
john boyle

14.89361702127659574468085106383% is the figure to 29 decimal places

to the OP basically you pay customs and excise the VAT in your profit

Reply to
lbockhed

OK Fair enough! When it comes to VAT I am very much believing in getting it thoroughly checked out, especially as so much money is at stake.

But as you say, if your confident enough then thats just fine.

I believe out of the government agencies to stay on the right side of......the VAT is the number one agency that has the overall most "ruthless and unconcerned" nature as opposed to the TAX Office.

So if you inadvertently make a mistake for some reason, you are less likely to get a freindly or undestanding response than from the TAX Office.

But thats only my humble opinion.

Reply to
Stephen GoldenGun

Who and where are your customers? If they include private individuals in other Member States, it gets complicated... You might have to register in those other States, as well as in the UK...

formatting link

Reply to
Nogood Boyo

Saints preserve us.

Reply to
Ronald Raygun

If you are selling £94 items for £100 currently (profit £6, margin 6%)

At £55,999 you will make £3,360 profit At £56,000 you will pay £8,340 Output VAT and on your purchases of £56,000 x 94/100 = £52,640 you will recover £7,840 of Input VAT leaving you £8,340 - £7,840 = £500 worse off.

Are you really operating such a high turnover on such low margins? You need an accountant. VAT registration can be (could be) avoided or mitigated, you have tax returns to complete and hefty fines if you miss your deadlines, lots of new legislation, profits (or in your case losses) to compute.

Reply to
Troy Steadman

In article , Troy Steadman writes

My concern was that, if the sellers you buy from are not VAT registered, you cannot reclaim the input VAT, because there is none.

Reply to
Richard Faulkner

In article , Stephen GoldenGun writes

Um, because this is Graeme who turns up every so often with an idea for a VAT scam!

Reply to
Timothy Lee

Indeed Richard and then things get *really* hairy! If I may quote myself:

With takings of £54,999 you will have an income of £54,999. With takings of £55,000 you will have an income of £46,808 and pay the VAT man £8,191 With takings of £64,624 you will have an income of £54,999 and pay the VAT man £9,625. So you earn less when your takings are £64,623 than you do when they are £54,999!

Reply to
Troy Steadman

But there may be "margin" scheme available?

Reply to
Doug Ramage

Soddit that's the wrong one again!

With takings of £55,999 you will have an income of £55,999. With takings of £56,000 you will have an income of £47,660 and pay the VAT man £8,340 With takings of £65,799 you will have an income of £55,999 and pay the VAT man £9,800. So you earn less when your takings are £65,798 than you do when they are £55,999!

:0(

Reply to
Troy Steadman

You are slightly wrong. Add 1 to each of your examples. You only have to register when you go *over* 56,000.

Best wishes

Robert Killington visit

formatting link
for help with VAT

To e-mail me please do so via my web site.

Reply to
Robert Killington

BeanSmart website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.